Ticketed by Technology: Chattanooga Drivers Question the Fairness of Speed Camera Fines

Ticketed by Technology: Chattanooga Drivers Question the Fairness of Speed Camera Fines

Sat, 27 Jul 2024 11:33:02 GMT

Controversy Over Chattanooga’s Use of Speed Cameras

In a developing controversy, drivers in Chattanooga, Tennessee, are raising questions regarding the fairness and enforceability of fines generated by speed cameras. Without the “blue lights in the rearview mirror,” many are shocked to discover they’ve been ticketed for speeding upon receiving a citation in the mail. The question now is whether these mail-in tickets are enforceable.

Speed Camera Locations and Public Perception

Speed cameras throughout the Chattanooga area, including near Highway 153, Hamill Road, Gadd Road, and the S-curves of Hixson Pike, have been issuing these citations. According to online discussions, many drivers have been surprised by the unexpected fines arriving in their mail. Confusion and uncertainty also revolve around whether these fines must be paid, leading to extensive debate among local road users.

The Enforcement Dilemma

Jay Kennamer, a representative of McMahan Law Firm, stated on Friday that a traffic citation due to camera-detected speeding is essentially a civil penalty, devoid of any legal implications affecting the offender’s driving records, insurance, or credit rating. However, what remains unclear is the potential consequences for non-payment.

Points of Contention

Two factors highlight the enforcement issue. First, Kennamer pointed out that these camera tickets are easy to contest due to their classification as civil penalties. Given that law enforcement is not present when the alleged violation occurs, genuine verification that the registered car owner was driving at the time of the offence is not possible. Therefore, in cases where a car or license plate might have been borrowed or stolen, the only existing evidence is a ticket and a tag.

State Legislature’s Stand on Issue

According to Representative Greg Martin (R) of Hamilton County, safety concerns over busy intersections and areas close to schools are the key reasons behind speed camera deployment. Despite his own dislike towards these monitoring tools, Martin acknowledges their effectiveness in encouraging cautious driving. However, he is also aware of the potential for misinterpretation of these civil penalties, maintaining that a human presence on the road is valuable for issuing proper warnings.

The Legal Perspective

In the unlikely event that the City of Chattanooga takes a driver to court over non-payment of a camera ticket, Kennamer suggests the chances of the case progressing beyond a civil complaint are slim. Given the filing fee of around $130, pursuing recovery of a $50 traffic violation fine seems unreasonable. Moreover, contesting these tickets should be straightforward given the inanimate nature of the evidence source: the speed camera.


HERE Chattanooga

Recent Posts

Exciting Times in Hamilton County: New Parental Leave Program Approved!

Exciting Times in Hamilton County: New Parental Leave Program Approved! Hey there, Hamilton County! There’s…

12 hours ago

Chattanooga Celebrates the Return of Christmas Kickoff Event at Hamilton Place Mall

Chattanooga's Holiday Spirit Shines Bright with Christmas Kickoff Chattanooga, get ready to spread some holiday…

12 hours ago

Exciting Groundbreaking Ceremony Set for East Ridge’s New Town-Center Complex on November 15!

Exciting Groundbreaking Ceremony Set for East Ridge's New Town-Center Complex! If you live in East…

12 hours ago

Chattanooga Commuters Face Weekend Traffic Changes on Interstate 24

Chattanooga Commuters Brace for New Traffic Pattern Chattanooga, it’s time to buckle up! Starting this…

12 hours ago

Chattanooga to Host Danish String Quartet for an Unforgettable Musical Evening

Chattanooga Welcomes the Delightful Danish String Quartet! Chattanooga is gearing up for an exciting evening…

12 hours ago

Chattanooga Community in Mourning After Fatal Wrong-Way Crash on Interstate 75

Chattanooga Community Shaken by Tragic Wrong-Way Crash CHATTANOOGA, Tenn. — A heartbreaking incident unfolded early…

12 hours ago